A policewoman sued her own force for nearly £5,000 after cutting her thumb while cleaning up a cannabis factory.
Kerry Ann Taylor, 34, won £4,837 by successfully arguing Hampshire Police breached its duty as an employer by exposing her to fumes and failing to provide thick gloves.
The WPC injured herself when she tried to open a window and put her hand through it.
Fumes from cannabis plants in the property had made her feel ill and she wanted to let in some fresh air.
It cost the force £145,000 in legal costs to take the case to London’s Court of Appeal this week in a battle to overturn the ruling, the Sunday Mirror reported today.
WPC Taylor’s lawyer Andrew Roy, urged the court to uphold the 2008 verdict because the flat-turned-drug factory in Southsea, Hampshire, was 'dangerous premises' with a foreseeable risk of injury.
He told the appeal judges: 'The only protective equipment provided was thin latex gloves.
'There was limited ventilation and her case, accepted by the judge, was she was suffering the effects of inhaling cannabis fumes.
'There was cannabis drying out and the place was a nest of wires.'
Geoffrey Weddell, for the police force, told the judges: 'WPC Taylor had simply not been allocated any task that required the provision of thick gloves.
'It is absurd to suggest the Chief Constable ought to have provided such gloves.'
And Lord Justice Elias said: 'She was
pulling out cannabis plants. There were no sharp edges involved at that
time. There is no obligation on the Chief Constable (to provide thick
gloves) at that point.'
Mr Roy argued that Hampshire Police’s own guidance at the time said officers entering cannabis factories should in fact be provided with body armour.
But Judge Elias said officers 'don’t need body armour' for going in to clean up a cannabis factory.
Judge David Blunt QC made the original ruling against then Chief Constable Alex Marshall at Winchester Crown Court in 2008.
The court reserved judgement until a later date in the case of WPC Taylor who is still with Hampshire Police.
A Police Federation spokeswoman told MailOnline: 'I can confirm that the matter is with the Court of Appeal.
'Whilst we await the judgement it would not be appropriate to comment further.'
The appeal came as it was revealed last week that a police officer was paid £10,000 compensation after falling off a chair on London Underground premises.
Details of the award to the British Transport Police officer were released after it emerged Norfolk Police officer Kelly Jones is suing a petrol station owner for £50,000 because she allegedly tripped while responding to a 999 call.
Kerry Ann Taylor, 34, won £4,837 by successfully arguing Hampshire Police breached its duty as an employer by exposing her to fumes and failing to provide thick gloves.
The WPC injured herself when she tried to open a window and put her hand through it.
Fumes from cannabis plants in the property had made her feel ill and she wanted to let in some fresh air.
It cost the force £145,000 in legal costs to take the case to London’s Court of Appeal this week in a battle to overturn the ruling, the Sunday Mirror reported today.
WPC Taylor’s lawyer Andrew Roy, urged the court to uphold the 2008 verdict because the flat-turned-drug factory in Southsea, Hampshire, was 'dangerous premises' with a foreseeable risk of injury.
He told the appeal judges: 'The only protective equipment provided was thin latex gloves.
'There was limited ventilation and her case, accepted by the judge, was she was suffering the effects of inhaling cannabis fumes.
'There was cannabis drying out and the place was a nest of wires.'
Geoffrey Weddell, for the police force, told the judges: 'WPC Taylor had simply not been allocated any task that required the provision of thick gloves.
'It is absurd to suggest the Chief Constable ought to have provided such gloves.'
(File picture) Hampshire WPC Kerry Ann Taylor,
34, claimed the force breached its duty as an employer by exposing her
to fumes and failing to provide thick gloves
Mr Roy argued that Hampshire Police’s own guidance at the time said officers entering cannabis factories should in fact be provided with body armour.
Heading force: Hampshire Police Chief Constable Andy Marsh
Judge David Blunt QC made the original ruling against then Chief Constable Alex Marshall at Winchester Crown Court in 2008.
The court reserved judgement until a later date in the case of WPC Taylor who is still with Hampshire Police.
A Police Federation spokeswoman told MailOnline: 'I can confirm that the matter is with the Court of Appeal.
'Whilst we await the judgement it would not be appropriate to comment further.'
The appeal came as it was revealed last week that a police officer was paid £10,000 compensation after falling off a chair on London Underground premises.
Details of the award to the British Transport Police officer were released after it emerged Norfolk Police officer Kelly Jones is suing a petrol station owner for £50,000 because she allegedly tripped while responding to a 999 call.